Looking for advice on adapting a videogame drinking menu (Runescape)

I wanted to make a real life alcohol menu based on Alfred Grimhand’s Barcrawl from Runescape. What drinks do you think would be good substitutes for the fantasy drinks? I’ve included the full list below with some superfluous details like price and ingame effect to help narrow down some of the more generic drinks.

Bar Location Name Price Effect Blue Moon Inn South Varrock Uncle Humphrey’s Gutrot 50 Lowers Attack, Defence, Strength, Smithing and Hitpoints. Makes you say, “Blearrgh!” Blurberry Bar Blurberry’s Bar Fire Toad Blast 10 Lowers health. Dead Man’s Chest Brimhaven Supergrog 15 Lowers Attack, Defence, Herblore, Cooking and Prayer. Causes double vision. Dragon Inn Yanille Fire Brandy 12 Lowers Attack and Defence. Blurs vision. Flying Horse Inn Ardougne Heart Stopper 8 Lowers health by about 20-30% of your total. Makes your eyes water. Forester’s Arms Seers’ Village Liverbane Ale 18 Lowers Attack, Defence, Fletching, Firemaking, and Woodcutting. Causes dizziness. Jolly Boar Inn North of Varrock Olde Suspiciouse 10 Lowers Attack, Defence, Mining, Crafting, and Magic. Makes your head spin. Karamja Spirits Bar Musa Point Ape Bite Liqueur 7 Rising Sun Falador Hand of Death Cocktail 70 Lowers Attack, Defence, Ranged, and Fishing. Lowers health. Makes the screen shake slightly for between 2–5 seconds. Rusty Anchor Port Sarim Black Skull Ale 8 Blurs vision. Causes hiccups.

I think I have some good ideas for the easy ones but I’m struggling with the Fire Toad Blast, Heart Stopper, Olde Suspiciouse, and Hand of Death Cocktail. I would also appreciate any specific suggestions for everything other than Uncle Humphrey’s Gutrot.

Uncle Humphrey’s Gutrot: home distilled whiskey

Fire Toad Blast: Some combination of a Blurberry Special and a Fruit Blast.

Blurberry Special: vodka, brandy, gin, lemon, orange, equa leaves, lime slices Fruit Blast: pineapple, lemon, orange Equa leaves: Small sweet smelling leaves.

Supergrog: high proof rum or non-diluted Bumbo (rum, sugar, nutmeg)

Fire Brandy: high proof Brandy

Heart Stopper:

Liverbane Ale: Fortified ale

Olde Suspiciouse: some old recipe

Ape Bite Liqueur: banana liqueur

Hand of Death Cocktail:

Black Skull Ale: dark ale